Appraisal Services

Appraisal Services

Vintage Magic has appraised nearly every important Magic: The Gathering rarity in the world. With over 23 years of appraisal experience, rest assured, you will receive the most accurate appraisal the first time around. To have your prized collectibles appraised by Vintage Magic, please read the details of the appraisal process below.


What does Vintage Magic provide appraisal(s) for?

  • Any mainstream published Magic: The Gathering (MTG) card, 1993 to Present
  • Any MTG Sealed Product(s) from 1993 to Present
  • Any Vintage Pokemon Ungraded/Graded Cards or Sealed Product(s) from 1999 to Present
  • Any MTG & Non-Magic Original Artwork(s)/Sketch(es)/Print(s)/Giclee(s)
  • Any Artist Proof(s)/Altered Card(s)/PIMP Card(s)
  • Any Misprint/Oddity/Miscut/Test Print card(s)
  • Any MTG Memorabilia/Artifact/Uncut Sheet(s)
  • Any Language(s)
  • Authenticity or Insurance Appraisals
  • Estate Appraisals
  • Vintage Magic Consignment Services (Appraisals are complimentary)
  • Vintage Magic Deck & Set Collector Fulfillment Service (Appraisals are complimentary)


What does Vintage Magic NOT provide appraisal(s) for?

  • NON-MTG (Yu-Gi-Oh, Sportscards, etc…) related collectibles
  • Stolen Merchandise


Does Vintage Magic do appraisals via email, Facebook, phone call, or text?

Vintage Magic does appraise individual item(s) but it must be inspected in person by a Vintage Magic representative. If you’re looking for a casual condition appraisal or authenticity verification, we do not offer that service. Email, Facebook, phone call or text questions have no way for us to verify the condition/authenticity of any item.

How do I start the appraisal process?

To begin your appraisal, click the contact us button below. A Vintage Magic Representative will contact you within 24 hours. Thank you again for your business interest in the Vintage Magic Appraisal Program!

Contact Us >>